Category Archives: Investing

A Reader Asks: SPIA inside of an IRA

Thank you for taking the time to read this blog post.  I recently received a rather complicated question from one of the frequent readers of this blog.  His question was about how he could buy an SPIA inside a Traditional IRA account.

The question came from a reader named Bill.  Bill provided me with a good amount of information about his financial situation.  Since I am not a financial advisor, I told Bill that I do not give financial advice, but would write about his situation on my blog and request feedback from other readers in the comment section.

Bill is 59 years old.  He is going to retire from his career as a truck driver next year when he turns 60 years old.  To fund his retirement, he owns three duplex rental properties that produce a generous income of $7,200 per month.  He has a portfolio of a few dividends paying individual stocks including Johnson & Johnson (JNJ) and Procter & Gamble (PG) worth $200,000.  Bill also has a safety deposit box full of EE Bonds that he has been buying for the past 30 years estimated to be worth about $50,000.  Bill also has a 401K with his long-time employer that has a balance of over $650,000.

Bill told me that the income from his rentals and the dividends that he receives is more than enough to cover all of his living expenses.  Bill is planning on taking Social Security at age 65, but if money gets tight for some unforeseen reason, he will tap Social Security at age 62 instead of 65.  Bill explained that he lives a frugal lifestyle and does not project that happening.

He wants to hold off on taking any money from his 401K that he is going to roll-over into an IRA until he turns 70 years old.  His goal is to grow the value of the IRA until he is required to take RMD’s.  Bill also wants to invest this money in a way that will provide guaranteed income in the future.

The exact phrase that Bill used was creating a growth and income strategy for himself.  He asked me what I thought about taking $600,000 from his IRA and buying a Single Premium Income Annuity (SPIA).  An annuity salesman from a major brokerage house quoted him a monthly payment of $2,800 per month, with 20 years certain, and a minimum payout of $665,000.

Bill does not want to spend the $2,800 per month at this time.  He wants to take the $2,800 per month and have it invested in a balanced mutual fund with a conservative asset allocation within the IRA.  His plan is to do this for 10 years.

At age 70, he wants to spend the $2,800 per month when RMD’s are required.  He projects that a balanced fund of 50% invested in stocks and 50% invested in bonds should return around 5% per year over the next 10 years.  That would provide him with another $440,000 in retirement savings.  Bill estimated his RMD’s to be around 4% and that $440,000 would give him an additional $1,400 in retirement income.

Bill asked me what I thought about his plan.  He was not concerned about receiving the best return on investment.  He was also not interested in any type of variable rate product.  He wants to have a guaranteed income at age 70, but also have some conservative growth over the next 10 years.

I am grateful that Bill took the time to send me an email about his unique idea.  He has set himself up for a comfortable retirement.  He just does not want to have to deal with market volatility and simply wants to buy himself a pension for the latter part of his life.

Bill does not want to put any of the $2,800 per month of future income in jeopardy.  Since he does not need it now, he wants to have it grow and earn a reasonable return. He referred to the extra $1,400 per month as gravy.  My thought was that the extra money could come in handy to offset future inflation.    

Since I am not a financial advisor and am not familiar with annuities, I told Bill that I would post his situation on my blog and ask for readers to comment.  My blog is read by many members of the financial independence community and a few financial advisors.  I will ask their opinion.

The main question that I have about Bill’s plan is can an SPIA be purchased in a traditional IRA?

What about the monthly payments, can they be kept within the IRA and be distributed to a mutual fund until RMD’s are due?

Would the combination of payments from the SPIA and withdrawals from a mutual fund impact the RMD’s when Bill is 70 years old?  

Thanks again for taking the time to read over Bill’s situation and plan.  Bill and I would truly appreciate any feedback about his plan of using an SPIA in an IRA to produce some growth and future income.  Please share in the comments section below if you have expertise or experience with using an SPIA in a Traditional IRA.

This post might contain affiliate links.

Please be sure to read the Disclaimer page.

Was it Luck or Good Habits?

Has anyone ever told you that you are lucky?  I don’t share my financial situation with many people.  I do on this blog, but I do so anonymously.  There have been a few times in my life when I broke my code of secrecy.  I share about my financial situation when someone asks me for financial advice.

I am not a financial advisor, so I cannot give advice on a professional level.  I can, however, share my experience with others.  People seem to get more out of a story than from a list of steps to follow.  This is where I started, this is what I did, this is where I am.

When I have shared my relative level of success, it was never to sound braggadocios.  It was always in the spirit of trying to help that person improve their financial situation.  Most of these conversations where started by them asking if I think they should take out a car loan or if they should start buying stocks.

I never share closed-ended answers.  I just share about how I navigated similar situations.  My approach is to let my results be their guide.

Most of these conversations were enlightening discussions for them.  The other person walked away surprised by what was financially possible if they applied some discipline in their life.  They thanked me for sharing my experience with them.  Some said that I was lucky to be in the financial shape that I was in.

That comment made me think.  Was I lucky?  I never thought of myself as unlucky, but I never thought about if luck contributed to my financial situation.

On some levels, I was lucky.  I was born into a stable and loving family who always supported me and would correct me when I needed it.  There have never been any major health issues in my life.  I also have been blessed with the most selfless person who I have ever met for a wife.  Yes, I do count my lucky stars every day for those blessings.


Debt causes me fear.  At a young age, I took out a small car loan.  The car ended up being a junk and I had a few grand in debt and nothing to show for it.  I swore off debt from then on.  Fortunately, debt spooked me at a young age.

Being afraid to go into debt forced me to work my way through college.  That allowed me to pay cash for my first two years of community college.  The only debt that I had to take was to pay for my second two years.  I came out owing only $18,000 and my student loans were only $156 per month.  Many of my coworkers had student loan payments of over $700 per month.  They lived in dorms, partied, took out the meal plan, and did not hold a job during college.

The same fear carried over when it was time to buy a house.  My wife had bought our house before we were married.  She was able to make payments on her salary alone.  Instead of moving to a bigger house in a new development, we just decided to stay in that house and pay it down quicker.


Saving money just came naturally for me.  I did not have debt, so I had money in my pocket.  The work that I performed for my first few years of full-time employment was hard manual labor.  It just felt like the right thing to do was to save the money.  It would have depressed me to blow it on what I felt was stupid crap.

My saving rate was always at least 30%.  Saving money was fun.  It was like a game.  How could I find ways to save more?

That mindset became ingrained in me.  As I earned more, I saved more.  Saving money gave me pleasure, so I kept doing it.

Saving is like exercise.  It is hard but addicting.  A hard workout is painful, but also provides pleasure.  There is a sacrifice with saving money, but the sense of accomplishment is more pleasurable to me than the feeling I get when money is wasted.


I did not want the money that I was working hard to save just sit in an FDIC checking account.  It would not grow fast enough there.  I wanted my money to grow and work for me.

After reading about compound interest, I decided to invest in mutual funds.  They felt like the right fit for me.  Individual stocks seemed to take up too much time with having to research companies.  With mutual funds, an investor can buy a basket of stocks in a single fund.

My approach to investing was based on life-cycle investing.  When I started investing, I did not have much money, so I wanted to maximize returns.  In my 20’s, I was invested 100% in stocks for about ten years.

After I had a nice little nest egg, I took some risk off the table.  I added some bonds to my asset allocation.  They helped reduce the volatility when the economy tanked in 2007-2009.

Ten years later, I reached financial independence and decided to add even more bonds to reduce risk.  The game is not over, but I have a big lead.  It is now time to run the ball and play stingy defense.  For the next ten years, I just need to earn about 6% based on my savings rate to reach my goal of early retirement.


I was lucky to be born with an able mind and body.  Yes, I have caught a few lucky breaks in my life.  However, I feel that I had taken the required actions and developed the right habits to put myself into the position to be successful.

Lottery winners are lucky.  I worked my butt off for everything I have.  I did not go into debt because I did not want to be backed into a corner by creditors.  Saving money seemed logical to me because I did not want to waste all that energy to just blow it.  As an investor, I took a risk and accepted market returns during booms as well as recessions.

Even though I do not believe that luck has had much to do with what I have achieved, I count my blessing every day.  Life has taught me that it is much better to be practice humility and to always help others.  As the result of all of that, I truly have a thankful and grateful heart.

This post might contain affiliate links.

Please be sure to read the Disclaimer Page.

Writing an Investment Statement Policy (ISP)

If you are familiar with this blog, you know that I like to have written plans.  The purpose of a plan is to have a guide.  I am not into hardcore manifestos that are rigid and do not allow room to make changes.  I like to have plans that are written in pencil and can be amended when opportunities present themselves.  An Investment Statment Policy is a good example of one such plan.

I believe in being intentional in life.  Before I act, I need to know what my intentions are.  In most situations, the outcomes are out of our hands, but the reasoning behind our actions are not.

By having a written financial plan, it is a map for our financial life.  A financial plan allows us to know where we currently are on the journey to financial independence.  It is also a guide to where we are going and what we should do when we reach different destinations on our financial journey.

As part of every financial plan, there should be an investment statement policy (ISP).  Nobody knows for sure where the economy is heading in the short term.  That is why it is considered wise to have an investment statement policy (ISP) to guide us along the way.

What type of an investor are you

Having an investment statement policy enables you to define who you are as an investor.  Are you a value investor who looks to buy low-priced stocks?  Do you follow a three-fund approach and like to own all the stocks in a market capitalization-weighted portfolio?  Are you comfortable with average market returns or do you try to beat the market by investing in actively managed mutual funds?  Do you invest in hot-trends like Bitcoin or alternative investments like crowdfunding?

By knowing the type of investor that you are will give direction to your decisions.  It will prevent you from chasing the hot investing tips that your coworkers are talking about at the water cooler.  Before you buy or sell an investment, you will look at your investment statement policy and ask yourself if it follows what you have established in your plan.

Know what you own

Without looking, could you list all your investments?  Could you explain why you own them?  What was your reasoning for adding a given ETF or individual security to your portfolio?

If you cannot list all your investments in less than a few minutes, you might have too many different investments.  If you cannot explain why you own an investment, you probably should not own that investment.  The same is true if you cannot give a sound reason as to why you bought an investment in the first place.

An investment statement policy can remove all those ambiguities that are tied to your investment decisions.  By having an ISP, you will know the why behind every investment in your portfolio.  Your investments will have a specific purpose in your portfolio.

Risk and return

Different asset classes come with different levels of risk and expected returns.  Conservative investments like FDIC insured savings accounts normally have low returns because the returns are guaranteed by the government.  Small-cap value stocks or emerging markets have higher than average returns because an investor is taking on more risk when they invest in these asset classes.

Do you know how much risk you are comfortable with?  Would you be able to keep buying more shares of an investment if it lost (30%) of its value in one year?  Do you think that you could hold onto an investment if it produced negative returns for a few years in a row?

By having an investment statement policy, these decisions will be made in advance.  If you have established that you see market volatility as a time to buy low, you will have established bands that will trigger when it is time to buy.  If you are not comfortable with short-term volatility, your investment statement policy will have already established a more conservative asset allocation that has less volatility.

Time Horizon

When will you be spending the money that you have invested?  Are you planning on retiring in 5 years, 15 years, or longer?  Knowing the answer to that question will help to establish how much of your money should be in equities and how much should be in fixed assets.

If you will not be retiring for ten or more years, holding a higher asset allocation of equities might be suitable for your situation.  If you are recently retired and are following the 4% rule, an asset allocation of 100% in stocks would be too aggressive due to market volatility.  When you are young you have time to recover from market corrections, but after you retire a (50%) market decline or prolonged recession could easily force a retiree back to work.

By having an investment statement policy, an investor can review their timeline annually.  An investment statement policy can help an investor with monitoring their path to retirement.  On that journey, the investment statement policy can guide them as to when it might be time to reduce some portfolio risk as retirement nears.

Monitoring Performance

Do you know what the expected return of your asset allocation is?  How is your portfolio performing this year?  Do you know how much your portfolio is up or down over the past 12-months?  Do you know what your average return was for the past 5 or 10 years?

Monitoring the daily performance of your investments is not helpful.  Listening to the daily market reports is an emotional roller coaster. In can do more harm than good and cause you to panic when there is short-term volatility.

By having an investment statement policy, you get to establish when you monitor your investment returns.  You can monitor your investments quarterly, twice per year, or annually.  If you are a passive investor, it could even be every other year.  It is your plan and up to you to establish how it will be monitored.  Personal Capital is a useful tool for monitoring the performance of your investments and it is free.

Skill Level

Are you a personal finance nerd?  Do you read investing forums, listen to podcasts, or attend local chapter meet-ups?  Do you write your own blog or are active in the financial independence community?  As a member of the financial independence community, you are most likely comfortable writing and updating your investment statement policy.

If you are not comfortable managing your own portfolio, there are many good financial advisors out there.  Even if you hire a professional to manage your money, work with them to help you to establish your investment statement policy.  You want to be sure that their decisions align with your needs and long-term goals.


Be intentional about your investment decisions and know the why behind every move.  Having an investment statement policy will help you to stay true to your long-term goals.  It is an invaluable part of a written financial plan.  An investment statement policy is useful to keep you focused on long-term goals when internal or external forces might be tempting you to stray.

After you write your investment statement policy, review it at least once per year.  Update it when needed.  Our financial situations are not static.  The investment statement policy will be different for everyone.  Your ISP will also change with time.  It is recommended to make amendments when a change is needed.  Just be sure that you can explain and make a sober justification for the change.

This post might contain affiliate links.

Please be sure to read the Disclaimer page.

Am I Financially Agnostic?

I am not new to investing.  I have been an individual investor for a couple of decades.  Over that period of time, I have seen it all.  There have been booms, bubbles, and busts.  As the result of my experience, I wonder if I have become financially agnostic.

Over that same period of time, I have not sold low as the markets bottomed out or experienced irrational exuberance when the market soared.  My goal has always been to reach financial independence by way of investing in stocks and bonds.  As the result of studying personal finance, I knew that markets go up and down.  Corrections and recessions occur.  They are an opportunity to buy low and to build long-term wealth.  When I started this journey, my time horizon was long and my risk tolerance was high.

Following 9/11, the markets melted down.  My Mom asked me if I was going to sell my stock holdings and not risk losing all of my savings.  I said nope and kept buying. The markets did not recover for more than three years and I did not deviate from my plan.  With every paycheck, I just kept dollar-cost-averaging into my investment accounts.

My response was similar following the market crash of 2008.  My wife asked if we should sell all of our stock holdings.  I said nope because we had a couple of decades to go until we retired.  I kept our asset allocation the same and kept dollar cost averaging.  2008 was scary and I did not know that the next bull market was only a few months away.

The same can be said for chasing performance.  When I started investing, day-trading and investing in technology stocks with high growth potential was crazy.  My experience as an investor was limited, but my gut told me that making money was truly not that easy.

During the early 2000’s, the real estate market was heating up.  Credit was easy to come by.  People who should not have been given loans were signing for variable rate mortgages without knowing the consequences of what future potential rate hikes would do to their monthly payment.  Investors without any real estate investing experience were flipping houses and condos all over the county.  Again, my gut told me to say away because I knew that making money was not that easy and speculators tend to lose their money when the markets make a turn for the worst.

So, why do I ask if you think I am financially agnostic?  It is not because I have no faith in capitalism or the global economy.  There is proof that investing in a market-weighted portfolio has worked in the past and I believe that it will continue to produce results in the future.  There will be ups and downs, but this type of investing will always provide average returns.

I classify myself as being financially agnostic because I do not believe in anything other than investing in a couple of index funds.  I do not know what the future market returns will be.  Whatever the markets do return, I am positioned to capture these returns.

Based on past performance, there are many financial institutions that I have no faith in.  They have mostly failed investors in the past.  They will continue to mislead in the future.  There is no way to know when to trust them and when not to trust them.

Financial Media

Even though it has improved to some degree, I have little faith in the financial media.  Yes, they have come around to indexing, but that does not sell advertising.  The financial media is out to make money and sell advertising.  The five hot stocks that they say to buy for summer will be different from the best wealth-building stocks they suggest for winter.  Fear sells magazines and newspapers.  It does not build wealth.  If the authors of these articles or the talking heads on television knew so much, they would be out making their own fortune and not reporting about financial news.

Financial Advisors

I have no faith in financial advisors.  Yes, there are some good fee-based financial advisors.  Most, however, are just salesmen.  They are just out to make a buck and do so by selling complicated investment products that come with high fees and low performance.  Collin Cowherd once said, “I trust Smith Barney when it comes to managing my money, but not Barney Smith”.  I guess Smith Barney has not done much better since they are no longer in business.  There has been some legislation around the financial industry to improve the quality of advice that financial advisors sell, but the financial industry has fought the concept of putting their client’s interests ahead of earning a commision.  There is currently no proof for me to trust these people with managing my money.

Actively Managed Mutual Funds

Professional money managers do not have a track record that garnishes much faith.  You would think that an actively managed mutual fund would outperform the index that they are benchmarked against, but the vast majority don’t.  Some outperform the index they track for a year or two.  Over the long hall, most actually underperform the index and go out of business.  They also are inefficient from a tax standpoint due to turnover as the result of all of the buying and selling of stocks within the fund.

The Financial Journeyman

This might or might not come as a surprise, but I also have no faith in myself when it comes to picking investments.  If both the Barney Smith’s and Smith Barney’s of the financial world cannot do it successfully, who am I to think that I can find alpha over the long term?  Easy answer, I cannot, so I do not even pretend to have any faith in my finite ability and resources to beat the market averages.  That is why I invest in my Sweet Dreams Portfolio and don’t pay too much attention to the markets.

History & Experience

Since I have little to no faith in all of those major financial institutions because they have all failed in the past, why do I have faith in the stock and bond market as a whole? My faith is based on experience.  By investing in index funds, an individual investor will outperform 90% of their peers.  I have captured average market returns for decades.  Those returns have allowed me to reach financial independence long before most people in my age group.  I have faith that my balanced-growth portfolio will produce average market returns.  By combining average market returns with a high savings rate and prudent living, I have faith that I will be able to retire early.  When I do retire, I will follow a similar approach with some scaled back risk during the drawdown period.


In life, I have learned to draw conclusions based on the evidence that is presented to me.  It is impossible to have trust in the financial industry that is not willing to take on a fiduciary responsibility.  Just as their goal is in to maximize ROI for shareholders, my goal is to earn the highest returns at the lowest costs to fund my retirement.  Up until this point, as well as moving forward, my faith is in playing the averages.

Are you financially agnostic?

Do you have any faith in the financial media, intuitions, or your own abilities as an investor?

Or, are you like me and believe in average market returns are both available and good enough to carry an investor too and through retirement?

This post might contain affiliate links.

Please be sure to read the Disclaimer page.

Using Beta to Measure Investment Risk

When an investment portfolio is being designed, there are a few basic factors to consider.  What is your age? What are your savings goals?  Do you know the type of returns do you expect to earn from your investments?  The most important factor to consider is much risk can you tolerate?  Using beta to measure investment risk is a great measurement to review.

When the stock market is soaring, investors tend to forget about risk.  Who wants to dampen the performance of their portfolio and miss out on the double-digit bull market returns?  It does not matter if you are an aggressive investor in your prime earning years or a more conservative investor who is nearing retirement when the markets start to get volatile, most investors tend to become more focused on risk management and risk tolerance.


It is important to know how risky the investments that make up your portfolio are.  One of the best ways to measure volatility is to measure the beta of an investment.  Beta is the second character of the Greek Alphabet.  Beta is used to determine how volatile an investment is in relation to its benchmark.

When measuring beta, the baseline is 1.  If an individual share of a publicly traded company, an EFT, or a mutual fund has a beta of 1, it moves exactly in step with its benchmark.  If an individual equity, ETF, or mutual fund has a beta that is greater than 1, the investment is more volatile than the benchmark that it tracks.  On the other hand, if an investment has a beta of less than 1, it would be less volatile than its benchmark.

In other words, beta is the risk measurement of investing in the stock market.  The stock market has a systematic risk.  If an investor wants to reduce the volatility of a market portfolio, they might want to consider adding some investments with a beta that is less than 1.

Investors who invest in a portfolio constructed of passive investments would generally be considered beta investors.  That is especially true for those who invest in broad market portfolios.  Investments such as large-cap index funds would have a beta of 1.  For example, an S&P 500 index would have a beta of 1 because it tracks the S&P 500 index. Investors who invest in a portfolio that incorporates bonds into their mix would have less volatility than a portfolio made up of only stocks because the beta would be less than 1. 

Below are a few mutual funds to consider if you are looking for a low beta option:

Fidelity Growth Strategies Fund FDEGX

Beta: 0.82

Fidelity Low-Priced Stock Fund FLPSX       

Beta: 0.54

Fidelity Small Cap Growth Fund FCPGX

Beta: 0.79

Vanguard Wellington Fund Investor Shares VWELX

Beta: 0.68

What are some investments that have a beta that is greater than 1?  It is not uncommon for actively managed mutual funds to have a beta higher than 1.  That is because fund managers are trying to beat the market.  There are index funds as well as ETFs that also have a beta higher than 1.  Micro-Cap funds and emerging markets tend to have a beta higher than 1. 

Some examples of funds with a high beta are:

ALPS Medical Breakthroughs EFT SBIO

Beta: 1.86

Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDS Fund XLY

Beta: 1.73

Fidelity Nasdaq Composite Index Tracking Stock ONEQ

Beta: 1.37

First Trust Dow Jones Select Micro-Cap Index Fund FDM

Beta: 1.33


While the beta is used to measure risk, alpha is the benchmark that measures market-beating performance.  Alpha is the goal of active managers.  Alpha is the Holy Grail of active management.  Those who consistently produce alpha become legends.  Those who don’t ultimately receive a pink slip.

Many investors would like a portfolio that has both a low beta score and a high alpha.  Building a portfolio that has the combination of low-volatility and market-beating returns is very hard to accomplish.  That is why most active fund managers do not succeed. 


Alpha is based on PR – [RF + Beta * (MR – RF)]

PR is the return produced by the investment portfolio

RF is the risk-free rate of return (Treasury Bonds)

MR is the market return

It is very difficult for active fund managers to consistently produce market-beating returns.  It is possible in the short-term, but the vast majority of managers do not beat their benchmark over long periods of time.  Most produce a negative alpha beyond 5 years.

It is almost impossible for individual investors to produce market-beating returns year after year.  Individual investors have a more difficult time than professional investors because they do not possess the resources or information that professional fund managers possess.  It would be easier for an individual investor to use beta to help in designing a portfolio than trying to produce long-term alpha.  


There are many factors to consider when building an investment portfolio.  Beta is one of many measurements to use as a guide.  It is not the sole measurement that should be the determining factor when trying to decide if an investment fits in with the rest of your portfolio.

Focus on learning how much real-world risk you can tolerate.  Could you tolerate a (50%) drop in the value of your portfolio?  If not, a portfolio of 100% invested in stocks might not be for you. How about a (20%) drop?  If that sounds more bearable, you should consider a more balanced portfolio. To help track your portfolio, consider using Personal Capital to monitor your asset allocation and performance.

Before you ever make an investment decision, be sure to check with an investment professional. 

Please be sure to read the Disclaimer page.

This post might contain affiliate links.