Balance is important in almost every area of life. We should eat a balanced diet including food from every food group to ensure our bodies get proper nutrition. We should balance the type of exercise we perform including strength training, cardio, and stretching. Having a good work-life balance leads to improved productivity and happiness. There should also be a balance in how we invest and that can be accomplished with a balanced portfolio.
To add balance as an investor means to invest in different asset classes that have an inverse relationship. A balanced portfolio is an asset allocation that has balanced percentages of stocks and bonds. It could be 50% invested in stocks and 50% invested in bonds. Most balanced portfolios utilize an asset allocation of 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds. However, the asset allocation might be outside of those bands.
The concept of the balanced portfolio was made popular by Harry Markowitz. In 1952, Harry Markowitz wrote a paper in the Journal of Finance where he introduced his hypothesis on Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT). The basic theory of Modern Portfolio Theory is that an investor can balance the expected return of a portfolio and risk by using diversification.
Modern Portfolio Theory suggests that an investor can construct an efficient frontier based portfolio by investing in more than one equity or fund. Portfolios that are based on the efficient frontier are highly diversified. The efficient frontier is a balance of diversifying across risky investments with a high potential for return with a low-risk investment that produces a lower return. The optimal portfolio is designed to strike a balance between securities that produce the highest potential returns with securities that have a lower potential for return but balance out the risk.
Sample Balanced Portfolios
There are many ways to construct a balanced portfolio. Below are two popular and simple balanced portfolios. They are both based on a 60/40 asset allocation. They incorporate a slightly different approach based on market capitalization.
The Coffee House Portfolio was created by a Bill Schultheis. Bill is a Seattle based financial advisor who created the Coffee House Portfolio for investors to build wealth, ignore Wall Street, and get on with their life. The Coffee House Portfolio is considered a lazy portfolio. Bill also published a book The Coffeehouse Investor that covers The Coffee House Portfolio in greater detail. The Coffee House Portfolio uses a tilt towards small cap stocks as well as value stocks. Small and value stocks have historically outperformed growth stocks. Value stocks are undervalued based on fundamental analysis. Please keep in mind, however, that there is no guarantee of this moving forward. This asset allocation is well suited for investors who prefer a slice-and-dice approach to asset allocation.
Large Blend – 10%
Large Value – 10%
Small Cap Blend – 10%
Small Cap Value – 10%
REITS – 10%
Total International – 10%
Total Bond Market – 40%
1-Year Return = 10.94%
5-Year Return = 6.63%
10 Year Return = 5.97%
Market Capitalization Weighted
Another lazy portfolio is the three-fund portfolio. While I am not sure if it was created by Taylor Larimore, it was made popular by him and the other Bogleheads in their book The Bogleheads’ Guide to Investing. The three-fund portfolio is made up of three mutual funds. Even though it only invests in 3 mutual funds, it invests in 10,000 stocks. This portfolio is highly tax-efficient because there is little turnover. It contains every domestic and international large-cap, mid-cap and small-cap stock. The three-fund portfolio is market cap weighted to prevent any front-running. There is not any risk of underperforming the market like with value tilting because this is the market. It is truly a simple portfolio to manage. It can be allocated in many ways to suit an investors goals and risk tolerance. Below is an example of how it can be used as a balanced 60/40 portfolio:
Total Stock Market – 40%
Total International Stock Market – 20%
Total Bond Market – 40%
1-Year Return = 7.05%
5-Year Return = 8.62
10-Year Return = 5.26
The best aspect of a balanced portfolio is that it allows the investor to control risk. It is not risk-free like an FDIC backed certificate of deposit. The risk is controlled by way of rebalancing. A balanced portfolio is easy to manage and rebalance when it falls out of alignment due to market performance.
Let us assume that there is a market correction and a decrease in the price of stocks. The portfolio that was once 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds is now out of alignment. The asset allocation is currently 55% in stocks and 45% in bonds. By rebalancing, the investor can sell bonds high and rebalance to the original asset allocation.
This systematic approach takes emotions out of the process and stands in the way of an investor making a poor decision. This prevents investors from chasing performance. It always forces the investor to buy low and sell high.
Just keep in mind that if this is done in a taxable account, it could trigger a tax consequence. It is best to rebalance in a 401K or IRA because it has zero impact on taxes. It is also wise to limit rebalancing to only once every year or no more than once every six months.
When it comes to investing, there is no such thing as having the perfect portfolio. By using a balanced portfolio, an investor can avoid putting all of their eggs in one basket. If an investor only invests in bonds their holdings will be secure, but the low returns might not keep up with the long-term rate of inflation. On the other hand, if an investor only invests in equities, a major market crash could cut the value of their life savings in half.
A balanced portfolio is a diversified portfolio. It reduces risk and can increase returns over the long term. A balanced portfolio can be customized to meet the risk tolerance and investment goals for investors in every age group. It can be created for both growth investors and for those who are seeking income.
A balanced portfolio can be constructed with many different funds or ETFs across various asset classes like the two above examples. Individual securities can be used as well. A balanced portfolio can also be made up of one mutual fund.
There are many options for investors who want to just use a single mutual fund. There are options for investors who like to use low-cost index funds. There are balanced funds for investors who prefer active management.
For investors who are near or in retirement, the Vanguard Wellesley Income Fund (VWINX) is a good option. The Wellesley Income Fund (VWINX) is actively managed and is composed of 40% in stocks and 60% in bonds. Even though it is an active fund, the Wellesley Income Fund (VWINX) has a low expense ratio of 0.22%.
Younger investors might want to own more stocks than bonds. A more aggressive balanced fund for them to consider is the Vanguard LifeStrategy Growth Fund (VASGX). The Vanguard LifeStrategy Growth Fund (VASGX) uses index funds for its allocation of 80% in stocks and 20% in bonds.
Just be aware that there is still a risk when investing in a balanced portfolio. A balanced portfolio just helps to reduce risk. It does not eliminate it.
An investor can design their own balanced portfolio. There are also mutual funds that allow investors to own a balanced portfolio with one single fund. There are options for investors of every age and risk tolerance profile. A balanced portfolio is a good option for both new as well as experienced investors.
This post might include affiliate links.
Please consult with a financial professional before you ever make any investment decisions and read the Disclaimer page.